
Brew facts
- Starring: Janel Parrish, Daniel Lissing, Jennifer Oleksiuk, Gabrielle Rose, Casey Manderson and Nat Buchanan.
- Premiere: October 24, 2026
- Director: Jessica Harmon
- Writers : Tracy Andreen and Lee Friedlander
- Streaming: Hallmark+ (US) or StackTV (Canada)
- Trope: Seconde Chance Romance
- My rating: ★★★★☆
☕️ First Slip
Kathryn and Rob are happily dating, so when he surprises her with a marriage proposal just before Christmas, you’d think she’d be thrilled. Instead, fear gets the better of her, and she runs away without giving him an answer. Then Rob gets into a car accident and loses his memories of the past year, including their relationship and his love of Christmas. With a little help from his doctor, Kathryn sets out to help him remember their story. But falling in love all over again isn’t necessarily as simple as retracing their steps.
🤩 What Went Down Smooth
First, can we talk about Daniel Lissing? This man has chemistry with practically every co-star he shares a screen with. I wasn’t always completely sold on Jack Thornton during my years watching When Calls the Heart, but between Single on the 25th last year and finally meeting Daniel at an event, I’ve become increasingly fond of him. He’s charming, genuinely talented, and particularly good at those vulnerable emotional moments.
I also love that Rob has such an unusual job: repairing antiques and old objects. It’s a refreshing change from the usual Hallmark professions, and it gives his character a little extra personality. He’s also a full-on Christmas enthusiast, which makes his sudden loss of holiday spirit all the more interesting.
What I found particularly compelling was the idea of Kathryn getting to experience the same love story twice, but not quite in the same way. There’s something bittersweet about hearing that Rob originally fell in love with her at first sight, only to realize that this time around, it isn’t happening that way. At the same time, she’s incredibly lucky to get another chance to fall for the same person, almost as if she’s experiencing their relationship for the very first time. It’s a lovely emotional contrast.
I also appreciated how Rob’s memories return gradually instead of all at once. Well, mostly gradually, the film eventually gives us the obligatory dramatic memory flashback, but I’ll forgive it. The soundtrack deserves a special mention, too. And that awkward, one-sided almost-kiss? Painfully uncomfortable for Kathryn, but genuinely well played. Not every romantic moment needs to be swoon-worthy!
The brother-in-law also deserves a little credit for bringing some welcome humour to the story.
🫤 What Left a Bitter Aftertaste
Kathryn’s initial refusal to accept the proposal takes a while to make sense, and the eventual explanation involving her teenage marriage and parents’ love lives adds another layer to her fear of commitment. Still, some of her decisions left me scratching my head.
Their first date with Rob’s entire family feels like a bold choice, especially considering how unwelcoming his mother initially seems. Although, to be fair, I eventually warmed up to her. After all, she apparently made her own husband propose three times before saying yes! You’d think she’d be a little more understanding of Kathryn’s hesitation. But then again, I suppose the story needed a little conflict.
I also found the early stages of their second courtship a little strange. Were they really that honest with each other during their first year together? New Rob is understandably more guarded after his accident, but the contrast between the two versions of him makes for some uncomfortable moments.
And what kind of restaurant considers a nice shirt insufficient without a jacket and tie? I have questions. Finally, where does Kathryn suddenly find $25,000 for a Christmas gift? That’s quite the holiday budget!
🔄 Worth a Refill?
Absolutely. Forgotten Holiday has a creative premise, a lovely soundtrack and, most importantly, a Daniel Lissing who knows exactly how to make an emotional scene land. The idea of getting a second chance to fall in love with the same person, but discovering that relationship all over again, gives the story more depth than I initially expected.
It’s not without its questionable moments, but I found myself increasingly invested in these two. Sometimes the best part of a second chance isn’t getting back what you had, it’s discovering what you could have done differently.





