
Brew facts
- Starring: Ashley Newbrough, Franco Lo Presti, Susan Hamann, Michael Gordin Shore and Carlisle J. Williams.
- Premiere: October 23, 2026
- Director: Max McGuire
- Writer : Alan Donahue
- Streaming: Hallmark+ (US) or StackTV (Canada)
- Trope: Seconde Chance/High School Romance
- My rating: ★★☆☆☆
☕️ First Slip
When globetrotting restaurateur Audrey returns to her hometown, she discovers that her late grandfather’s beloved bowling alley, Wonderlanes, is about to be sold. Determined to give it one last festive season, she revives its traditional youth bowling tournament and teams up with Jason, her high school sweetheart and a local reporter. Between old memories, second chances and a possible new beginning, Audrey must decide where she really belongs.
🤩 What Went Down Smooth
I’m a sucker for a good vintage small-town atmosphere, and Winter Wonderlanes delivers on that front. The bowling alley, the diner and the whole town have a lovely retro aesthetic that almost makes you feel like you’ve stepped into the 1960s. It gives the movie a distinct personality, even if I would have liked a little more Christmas sprinkled throughout. At times, this could easily pass for a regular romantic movie.
And can we talk about the hair? Jason’s glorious head of hair deserves its own supporting credit. Seriously, that’s some impressive volume!
The pyjama night at the bowling alley is another idea I can absolutely get behind. Cozy, fun and exactly the kind of community event that makes a small-town Christmas movie feel charming.
🫤 What Left a Bitter Aftertaste
The teenage versions of Audrey is quite a distraction. The resemblance to her adult counterpart is so limited that I found myself wondering whether the casting team had even tried to make them look related.
I also wasn’t entirely sold on the chemistry between Audrey and Jason. Second-chance romances need us to believe there was something worth rekindling, and I didn’t quite feel that spark.
Some of the story details also left me scratching my head. Making customers untangle Christmas lights in exchange for a free bowling game? I’m not sure I’d call that a festive promotion. And is a multi-generational bowling alley really the most exciting assignment for a local journalist? I’m not convinced.
🔄 Worth a Refill?
Winter Wonderlanes has a charming vintage setting and a few fun ideas, but it doesn’t quite make the most of them. The Christmas atmosphere is surprisingly understated, and the central romance didn’t fully win me over.
I enjoyed the bowling alley, the retro town and the cozy community spirit more than the love story itself. It’s a pleasant enough watch if you enjoy small-town nostalgia, but I wouldn’t put it at the top of my Christmas movie list. Sometimes the setting strikes a better deal than the romance.





